The Faulty Sieve

Some stories come from the most unexpected places. This one started with a conversation with someone I’d never met before. What stayed with me wasn’t just his experience as a candidate- it was the lesson hidden behind it.

Today, Angel leads teams and interviews candidates himself. Years ago, however, he was the person sitting on the other side of the table. What should have been an interview quickly turned into something else. The interviewer spent most of the meeting talking on the phone, walking around the room, and explaining how “complex” the organization was and how difficult it was to find people who could fit in.

Not a single meaningful question was asked about Angel’s experience, skills, or motivation. There was no curiosity. No conversation. No interview.

Eventually, Angel ended the meeting himself. He politely apologized for taking up their time and left - not out of arrogance, but out of self-respect.

About a year later, they crossed paths again while working on a shared project. This time, he met the company’s owner. After seeing the way Angel worked, the owner said something that caught him by surprise:

“I’d give anything to have people like you on my team.”

Angel’s reply was simple.

“I came to your company a year ago. The problem wasn’t that you couldn’t find people. The problem was that the sieve at your entrance had the wrong holes. It wasn’t filtering talent in - it was filtering talent out, straight to your competitors.”

That metaphor stayed with me.

Because this isn’t really a story about one bad interviewer.

It’s a story about a hiring process that quietly works against itself.

The real problem

Organizations often assume they lose candidates because:

• the market is competitive;

• expectations are too high;

• good talent is hard to find.

  
  

Sometimes the explanation is much simpler. They lose great people before the hiring process has even had a chance to begin.

Poor recruitment doesn’t drive away unqualified candidates.

More often, it drives away the people who know their value. The professionals who expect respect.

The ones who don’t feel the need to convince someone they deserve to be heard.

The biggest risk?

The company often never realizes it has just lost exactly the person it was looking for.

My reflection

Hiring is not an administrative task.

The people who stand at the entrance of the company ultimately shape the team that will exist one, three, or five years from now.

When interviews become routine, when attention disappears, when respect is replaced by process, the damage goes far beyond one negative candidate experience.

It reveals something about the organization itself.

Today, before every interview, Angel asks himself one simple question:

“How does the person sitting across from me feel right now?”

I ask myself exactly the same question.

The answer isn’t always comfortable.

But I believe that’s the difference between conducting interviews and truly understanding recruitment.

The real question isn’t whether enough candidates apply.

The real question is whether your hiring process is capable of recognizing the right ones when they do.

Three lessons for organizations

1. The people at the entrance shape the future of the company.

Interviewing isn’t an administrative responsibility. It’s a strategic one. Every interviewer represents the organization and influences who chooses to join it.

2. Every candidate experience matters - even without an offer.

Every interaction either strengthens or weakens your employer brand. People may forget a rejection, but they rarely forget how they were treated.

3. Before blaming the market, examine the process.

Sometimes the problem isn’t the talent pool.

Sometimes it’s the sieve.

Culture doesn’t begin on an employee’s first day.

It begins with the very first conversation.

If the entrance is broken, everything that follows is built on compromise.

If you enjoyed this article:

1️⃣ Subscribe to The Candidate’s Voice on LinkedIn to receive future stories and insights.

2️⃣ If your organization is looking to improve its hiring process, strengthen its recruitment strategy, or create a better candidate experience, I’d be happy to explore how I can help.

3️⃣ Have a story from the other side of the interview? I’d love to hear it.